DIY Freezer Butter Cookies

Homemade Freezer Butter Cookie dough leads to on-demand fresh baked cookies whenever you like in just 10 minutes. These are sweet, but not too sweet. So, they’re great for dessert or to serve with coffee or tea as a weekend breakfast.

Even if you don’t eat sweets very often, these are a great idea for the random craving every few weeks. It’ll save you money, save you time and still be healthier than the store-bought version since you control the ingredients.

They’re also great for making guests feel special because it’ll look like you went through the effort of making them homemade cookies. But little do they know that you actually keep fresh baked cookies on tap. But hey, no harm in making someone feel special! 😀

🍽️ Why This Recipe Works

Ready When You Are – These cookies are the perfect “I need some sweets now!” solution in your house. By keeping a little cookie dough ready in the freezer, you are able to whip up cookies whenever you would like.

Quick and Easy – You can’t beat recipes that are quick and easy to make to save you time to do other things. Who doesn’t love something homemade but would like to skip the hours needed to do it. These take less than 15 minutes to make the batter and put in the freezer.

🧈 Ingredients

Imagine how easy it is to make cookies with just six ingredients! They are mind-blowing delicious too! Let’s talk a little further about a few of the ingredients.

Butter:  It’s super important to use butter that is at room temperature. It blends so much easier and produces a lot creamier cookie.

Light Brown Sugar: You’ll get the perfect amount of sweetness in every bite when you use a little light brown sugar. For these cookies brown sugar is a much better fit than white sugar.

Vanilla Extract: Is a good quality pure vanilla extract for best results. If you want to get a little playful you could swap the vanilla for almond extract instead.

🍪 Instructions

Step One: Using the back of a spatula to mix butter until creamy.

Step Two: Mix the butter and sugar together until it is combined well. Beat in egg and vanilla extract.

Step Three: In a separate bowl, combine salt and flour together and incorporate into the wet mixture and combine until dough forms. The dough should be “cleaning” the bowl by picking up most pieces that were stuck to the side.

Step Four: Sprinkle a bit of flour lightly on countertop, transfer dough and form it into a rectangular log. Wrap in plastic wrap and place in freezer for thirty minutes. The trick to getting the dough smooth and uniformly shaped is to smooth it once it’s in the plastic wrap.

Tip: If you’re a perfectionist, you can push the sides of the cookie dough log against a flat surface (like a cutting board) for a more uniform shape.

Step Five: Remove the loaf from the freezer and cut it into ¼ inch rectangles. Place those on a cookie sheet and freeze for at least three hours.

Step Six: If you prefer to only use one cookie sheet, you can freeze in layers, separating each layer of cookies with aluminum foil so they do not stick to one another.

Step Seven: Remove from freezer, transfer to freezer bag. Store these for up to three months.

👩‍🍳 Baking Instructions

When the sweet tooth is screaming, it’s time to pull your cookie dough out of the freezer. Here’s what to do next in under 15 minutes.

Step One: Place frozen cookies on cookie sheet, and preheat oven to 350. The cookies will thaw slightly while the oven preheats.

Step Two: Bake for 10 to 14 minutes, or until the tops are firm to the touch and the bottoms are lightly browned.

❗ Expert Tips

Make sure to store these in freezer grade Ziploc bags so they will stay fresh from any freezer burn. If you don’t have any, double or triple wrap the cookies with Saran or Press N Seal so they have the best change to stay fresh.

Make sure that the butter is at room temperature so it will be creamy. If it is still a little bit cold, it’s difficult to get those little round pebbles of cold butter all blended together.

When making cookies, it’s wise to measure your dry goods the correct way. If you SCOOP the dry measuring cup into the flour container, you have a chance to add 2-3 tbsp of flour to your batter. That doesn’t sound like a big deal, but it can make your cookies dry. Always SPOON the flour into dry measuring cups and then level off with the back of the knife.

Tried this recipe? Please leave a star ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ rating in the recipe card below and/or a review in the comments section further down the page. You can also stay in touch with me through social media by following me on Instagram, Pinterest, and Facebook!