Homemade Pistachio Butter has taken our house by storm! It is extremely easy to make and looks just as great as it tastes!
Alternative nut butters are the rage (ok, so I knew that….just missed the pistachio butter memo!) right now, giving our good ol’ peanut butter a run for the money. Making your own nut butter is so simple that it is hard to go back to a traditional jarred version. The taste of natural nut butters will have you never tasting Skippy again…sorry Skip.
Pistachio Butter is made by removing the outer shell of the pistachio to reveal the green nut center. Blending or grinding it releases the oils to make it super creamy. The best part of making your own Pistachio Butter is that you can add a touch of salt or a little sweetener, all to your own liking. You know exactly what went into it and you don’t have to worry about the health impacts of any mystery ingredients.
🍽️ What does it Taste Like?
Pistachio Butter is an extremely mild nut butter. My whole family agreed that it has a mild earthy flavor to it. I think the green color may turn some people off, but I thought it was fun!
🍴How to Use
Pistachio Butter is used for so many things other than a direct replacement of peanut butter. Pistachio Butter is found in many desserts like crepes, truffles, cookies and even ice cream. Don’t forget to spread it on baked goods for a flavorful treat or as a protein boost in overnight oats.
🥄 How Long Does it Last?
Pistachio Butter can last indefinitely in the refrigerator according to the American Pistachio Growers. You also have the option to not refrigerate it and it will last for a couple weeks.
💵 Why Are Pistachios So Expensive?
According to the Western Nut Company:
- It takes pistachio trees 15-20 years to become ready to become a nut producer.
- Once the tree is fully grown, it only produces 50 pounds of nuts per year compared to brazilan nuts that produce 250 pounds in the same amount of time.
- The pistachio trees need a very specific climate that has cool winters and long, hot summers.
- Pistachio trees are grown only in California, Turkey and Iran.
If you take all of that into account, it quickly adds up why the nuts are so expensive.
🥣 Are Pistachios Good for You?
Absolutely! Pistachios help reduce bad cholesterol and increase the good cholesterol which helps fight against heart disease. There is also research stating that it helps reduce inflammation and helps diabetes.
You won’t believe how simple it is to make your own homemade pistachio butter. All you need is three ingredients, and you will be enjoying your new favorite condiment.
Pistachios – For the best results, use roasted and unsalted pistachios. We will be adding in some salt ourselves. This allows you to control the saltiness, and it will taste better when it’s not overly salty.
Salt – As I mentioned, you can add in some salt to flavor the pistachio butter. Don’t go too wild and it will be perfect.
Coconut Oil – Use refined coconut oil if you do not want to have the flavor of coconut in your pistachio butter. The coconut oil enhances the overall texture and the way the pistachio butter spreads onto food.
🍋 Make in a Food Processor
Step One: If your pistachios are not roasted, take a few minutes to roast them now. While the shells are still on, place the pistachios on a sheet pan and set the oven temperature to 350 degrees and roast for six minutes. Allow the nuts to come back to room temperature.
Step Two: Remove the shells from the nuts. This will take a bit of time, so share the task with your better half. Your fingers will probably get a little sore by the end!
Step Three: Place the nuts, salt and melted coconut butter in a food processor and turn on to start to blend. This process will take 6-8 minutes. From time to time, take the lid off the food processor and scrape down the nut butter. Keep checking and scraping it as needed. In a food processor, I assure you, it will take the full 6-8 minutes before the nuts are processed into a smooth and creamy consistency. It is really fascinating to watch the oils release and turn this into a creamy butter.
🥄 Make in a Vitamix
Place the roasted/shelled nuts in the Vitamix along with the salt and coconut oil and turn it to a medium speed. You will need to tamp it often to keep it moving around but it will be done in under two minutes. The only drawback to making Pistachio Butter in the Vitamix for me is that it is hard to get every last bit out from under the blade. Given how expensive those nuts are, I opt for the food processor as I can scrape every last bit out.
📌 Should You Blanch the Nuts?
To get the brightest green pistachio nut butter, you can blanch the shelled nuts by adding them to a pot of boiling water for a few seconds. The hot water will loosen the skin of the nut. After removing them from the water, briskly rub them between two thick paper towels to loosen the skin.
The benefit of this is that it will result in a nut butter that is even more bright green; however, the skins contain valuable nutrients and antioxidants.
🍲 Can You Meal Prep?
Absolutely! There are two steps that are perfect for prepping.
- Roast the pistachios and allow to cool.
- Start shelling as this is the most time consuming task.
If you complete these two tasks, you will cut down the amount of time to make pistachio butter!
🧈 Related Recipes
Almond Butter is made the exact same way so if you know how to make one, you can make them both!
How to Make Tahini teaches you how to use toasted sesame seeds to make your own tahini instead of buying it. From this point, you can use it to make the Roasted Red Pepper Hummus-absolutely to die for appetizer or the Roasted Red Pepper Tahini Sheet Pan Cauliflower side dish! I love eating this one when eating meatless days since the added protein from the tahini is a boost.
If you are a huge lover of pistachios like we are, check out:
20+ of the Best Pistachio Recipes to fill that pistachio craving! Creative ideas to use pistachios in new and innovative ways!
Homemade Pistachio Butter
- 16 oz roasted, unsalted pistachios
- pinch salt
- 1/2 tsp coconut oil
- Place all of the ingredients into a sturdy food processor. Put lid on and start to blend.
- Keep blending. If the food processor seems to need to have the butter sticking to the sides, open up the lid and scrape down from time to time.
- Keep blending for 6-8 minutes. As you watch the sides, you will see the butter change many times until it becomes smooth like a peanut butter appears.
- Remove and place in jar.